Many people ask themselves, "Is Tin Cheaper Than Asphalt Roofing?" when deciding between roofing materials.With a lower initial cost per square foot, asphalt roofing is typically the more economical choice, which appeals to homeowners on a tight budget. However, tin roofing has a larger initial cost but is more long-lasting and durable. A tin roof might be a preferable option for people that value long-term investment over short-term savings. Tin can provide superior value over time because of its robustness and minimal maintenance needs, although asphalt is preferable for short-term purposes.